#QUESTIONING THE STATUS QUO
Explore tagged Tumblr posts
Text
I find the fact that the confrontation at the end of UTRH is often summarized as Jason asking Bruce to kill the Joker for him fascinating.
Because that's not what happened.
Jason holds a gun up to Joker's head, gives Bruce another, and tells him that if Bruce doesn't do something (shoot Jason), he will kill Joker.
Jason doesn't give the gun to Bruce so that he would shoot Joker. He isn't expecting Bruce to pull the trigger on the clown. He's asking Bruce to do nothing. To be inactive. Because that will still be a choice, and despite having done nothing, everybody clearly agrees that Bruce would still, at least in part, be responsible for Joker's death.
...And to me, this moment is a kind of- microcosm, of the rest of Jason's point. Because after being captured and carted off to Arkham, the villain will escape again, and will kill more people. The only way to truly prevent that from happening would be to kill them; Bruce refuses to do so, and I respect his right to choose such a thing for himself, but it is still a choice, and if we agree that Bruce's inaction during the confrontation would leave him at least partly responsible for the Joker's death, then we must also agree that his inaction in permanently preventing the Rogues from killing more people means he is also, partly, responsible for all of those deaths.
#my dc posting#batman#dc#bruce wayne#jason todd#joker#uhh is this like analysis or meta#anyway. to me this is the message that scene sends#if we say bruce doing nothing would mean he assisted in the murder of joker then bruce doing nothing about the villains means he is also#responsible for those deaths#ANYWAY yes b4 you come at me;;#bruce's belief in rehabilitation and that everyone can get better is central to his character#and i love it and no i dont actually think he should kill the rogues or whatever#but the question there is. Are you fine with the future victims your decisions will cause?#Are their lives worth the slim chance any of these people will get better?#batman says yes theyre worth it. red hood says no theyre not.#thats the fundamental moral difference there#its why jason challenges the batman status quo#which is why he cant be harnessed well after his initial return bc comics can never truly escape that status quo#anyway i sure am having some thoughts for someone not that smart so if you disagree please tell me!!! just be civil or ill just block you <#...anyway this is another thing BTAS succeeds in bc i always feel like yes these villains do deserve yet another chance#despite what theyve done. bruce's belief in them doesnt feel stupid and naive#its abt what you yourself can live with. bruce can live w the deaths of the ppl the criminals he doesnt get rid of kill#and jason can live with killing those criminals and preventing further victims
1K notes
·
View notes
Text
vox and velvette are dangerous in part because of how desperatedly they want to conform to certain social norms and valentino is dangerous im part because of how little he cares to
#DO YOU UNDERSTAAANDDD#VOX AND VEL SOCIAL NORMS IN QUESTION: WHITE PATRIARCHY.#VALS SOCIAL NORMS IN QUESTION: BASIC RESPECT OF OTHER PEOPLES WELL BEIJG AND AUTONOMY#ohh ill go crazy. ill die#is it not completely insane the vees are both the opressive centuries long status quo and the transgressive#hazbin hotel#hazbin the vees#this is also why theyre in love#humm also two diehard capitalists and one good old money hungry bitch#ive stopped making sense a few tags ago#vettie#the vees#my tags
62 notes
·
View notes
Note
man I NEED to hear what you think about Bakugo
Alright I dropped MHA (because of Mineta, Bakugo, and Aizawa, mostly), so I’m going with maybe half the series in mind, but I’ll try to compose my thoughts on this pretty quickly, going of my own watching and some general pop-culture osmosis.
Katsuki Bakugo’s very existence in the story of My Hero Academia breaks an extremely important core message that the show tries to send- “You should intervene in situations when wrongdoing is occuring, even if the victim is “good” (eg: stoic, strong, handling it well, Shouto being extremely composed and powerful, Bakugo being attacked by the slime monster, Eri holding herself together in spite of everything she’s gone through) or “bad” (eg: unattractive, poor, manic, Shigaraki being turned up by the old lady, Toga being forced suppress herself), because even trying and failing or just reaching will at least make an impact or offer a light in that dark tunnel (All Might selecting Izuku after he saves Bakugo, Shouto accepting the fire half of his Quirk after Deku reaches out to him)-
In other words, “Meddling when you don't need to is the essence of being a hero!”
So when MHA shows me this whole cast of children who are supposed to be “the next generation of heroes” and expect me to root for them, I can’t help but note that none of them ever try and stop the violent bully in their midst. They might disapprove or refuse to engage, but there’s never a moment that any of these “heroes-to-be” say “Hmm. Maybe if someone is threatening the life of my kindly classmate- especially in a form as immediate as unleashing literal explosions at him and needed to be physically restrained, I should intervene.”
They, and almost all of the faculty and staff, ignore this legitimately unhinged and violent child running amok, are not “true heroes” by the messaging and morals of the narrative itself, because they sit on their asses and allow a bully (and Mineta, the rat fuck) to do as he pleases- when a reaction does occur, it’s more along the lines of scolding/laughing at a toddler for cursing/throwing a fit than “holy shit, this kid is a violent threat to at least one of our other students, we need to intervene now”.
I don’t know, maybe this is addressed later in the series, maybe Horikoshi pulls some crazy shit to justify it, that could be what happens by the end.
I just couldn’t watch to that point, if it does exist.
TLDR: Katsuki Bakugo you will never be Cristopher Skyline
#Time Talks#My Hero Academia#MHA#MHA Critical#MHA Analysis#Bakugo#Katsuki Bakugo#It doesn’t help that Horikoshi never actually addressed the suicide baiting#You CANNOT have a character pull a move like that and never follow up on it#I think Ol’ Hori was on a fucking leash throughout MHA to be fair#Feels like every time he was about to do something potentially profound a higher up said ‘No. status quo and big punches only’.#Just a lot of cool concepts (heteromorph racism/corrupt heroes/Quirkless discrimination) that are hyped and then kinda dropped#or resigned to a single character/downplayed after being built up#Anon Questions#At least Bakugo has one thing he excels at: Ending the careers of Pro-Heroes
60 notes
·
View notes
Text
less "this story has no romance in it" and "this story has aspec characters in it", more "this story is about aromantic people and aromanticism" please and thank you
#i mean there's nothing wrong with the first two options#but i really really want to read aro stories#like stories told from the pov of aro characters#stories about aro characters#stories that question the status quo of “romance above everything else”#and “love above everything else”#bit tired of most recommended "aro stories” actually meaning “romance isn't the focus that's what the aros want right?”#im on my aro bs again can you tell#aromantic#aro#queer stuff
367 notes
·
View notes
Text
boy do i love how the only reason bioware replaced Lucerni with Shadow Dragons was because they wanted middle class citizens being the driving force of the changes for Tevinter.....
.......... and STILL ended up with them being run by a former member of magisterium, a rich altus diplomat and a fucking BLACK DIVINE
#veilguard critical#dragon age#dav#no i can understand that desire for change honestly#it's shitty when the most privileged are the ones who make decisions#although there is a bit of truth to that. ppl who are educated are more likely realize that system is failing#rather than uneducated and abused slaves who is kept uneducated and abused FOR A REASON#but it also brings a lot of questions and skepticism to motivations of dorian and his pals#like ok babyboy you wanna change tevinter cuz your dad tried to change you with blood magic#how am i supposed to believe you're gonna change anything substantial? something that ACTUALLY matters#and that goes for the rest of lucerni. how am i supposed to believe you assholes are gonna change anything and not just put another archon#who's only difference would be that he's loyal to YOU?#and the funny thing is bw didn't fix shit#the altus is still ruling. elven cultural appropriation is not even ACKNOWLEDGED. slavery.... well there was no slavery to begin with!#keep the status quo guys or you'll be like evil evil bald guy who's bad and should be jailed unlike the slavers and#i'm rambling again now leave me#bioware critical
27 notes
·
View notes
Text
Fanfics in which Marcy and Sasha idealize Anne as this angelic being filled with kindness and light are so sweet but also so funny. It's always abt how they feel like they don't deserve her because of all the harm they caused her but also. Lmao you can tell they weren't around Wartwood in S1. Anne was such a little piece of shit back then.
#amphibia#my posts#sashannarcy#s1 Anne still ends up coming across as leagues better than sasha and marcy because her bad deeds were more of a#they were very casual and small potatoes. Anne's shitty behavior was more of a matter of quantity than quality#pressuring sprig to confess to ivy as a main attraction at her frog of the year party#shaming polly for not being girly enough#pretending to be sick to avoid work causing the plantars to get sick themselves#this is opposed to marcy committing only three big crimes. but those were BIG#1) kidnapping her friends 2) doubling down on it by striking a deal with Andrias. lying to them and manipulating them for months#and 3) never taking a side in sasha and anne's argument. which i think is a BIG thing and i wish we mentioned it more because#she's not brave enough to take anne's side she's not brave enough to question sasha and her struggle to maintain the status quo#is hurting everyone#and sasha... do i even have to elaborate 😭
34 notes
·
View notes
Text
maybe im overthinking, but do you ever think abt how in episode 1, utena justifies wearing the boys uniform by saying its not against the rules? while this was clearly a "gotcha" moment against that stuffy teacher, i feel like it also shows how shes still functioning within the parameters of the ohtori system. like, yeah, shes being rebellious, but its a form of rebellion that isnt actually revolutionary- shes still following the rules propagating the structure built around the patriarchal prince, shes just doing it in the "opposite" way of whats expected, but shes not actually fighting it. though, of course, even this much deviance still tries to get corrected... its still not against the rules. i feel like from the beginning we're told aspiring to princedom isn't a noble goal, and that utena is still part of the system as long as she pursues it
#idk compare it to... you know pop feminism thats like ''lipstick red enough to kill a man'' type stuff?#obvs thats going in the more fem direction but its like... still perpetuating the patriarchy in the end#its an empty movement (lol) that doesnt actually mean shit bc it doesnt challenge the status quo#the point is its not ''against the rules.'' thats an irl thing i can think of comparing it to at least#but yeah i also think it answers the question of ''how come a school SO obsessed w gender norms doesnt enforce a stricter dress code?''#is bc as long as you play a role to propagate the system it doesnt really matter#though at the end all girls are like the rose bride etc etc i also think thats an aspect of it#like how gender nonconformity is often seen as ok in young girls- the ''tomboy'' phase thats seen as frivolous#and something theyll grow out of. or something theyll be made to grow out of. i very much think that plays into it too#its okay when youre a girl but when youre a woman you have to become a bride. literally and figuratively#rgu
72 notes
·
View notes
Text
Ponder rolled his eyes. These things always sounded fine when he worked them out in his head. He'd read some of the old books, and sit and think for ages, and a little theory would put itself together in his head in a row of little shiny blocks, and then when he let it out it'd run straight into the Faculty and one of them, one of them, would always ask some bloody stupid question which he couldn't quite answer at the moment. How could you ever make any progress against minds like that? If some god somewhere had said, "Let there be light," they'd be the ones to say things like, "Why? The darkness has always been good enough for us."
Terry Pratchett, The Last Continent
#ponder stibbons#unseen university#the last continent#discworld#terry pratchett#wizards#academic#faculty#assistant professor#coworkers#progress#new ideas#tradition#status quo#bloody stupid question#good enough for us
164 notes
·
View notes
Text
I love the line, "They sell presentable, young and so ingestible, sterile and collectible, safe, and I can't stand it," SO much. It really gets at the heart of what so much of Danger Days is trying to say imo. And I especially love the sort of visceral note in the phrase "young and so ingestible" - like obviously the image of art and artist as something to be consumed has been around for ages and it doesn't have to evoke anything so literal as the audience wanting to physically eat the band, but it certainly calls that to mind for me, and the idea that the music industry (and capitalism more broadly) exists to facilitate and encourage that desire is just... chef's kiss.
#danger days is a work of legitimately interesting anti-capitalist critique and i love that for her#the question of how to be an artist in a late capitalist society that wants to sell your voice and package your rebellion as a commodity#that ultimately serves and upholds the status quo is a really interesting one that gets explored in this verse and also sing#it's just a good fuckin album is i guess what i'm saying#mcr#my chemical romance#danger days#danger days the true lives of the fabulous killjoys#ddttlotfk#ttlotfk#danger days era#planetary (go!)
39 notes
·
View notes
Text
adaine's family relationships are something i can actually be so incredibly normal about too btw
#like. a little bit later adaine's father gives her a useless orb for spell casting#and she points out it's not practical and he says 'i try my best with you! i really do!'#like. it's about parents who fundamentally don't understand you#it's about parents who have such a narrow and rigid idea of what's acceptable that when you start to find yourself outside of it#they can't even recognize you.#it's about watching your sister (aelwyn) seamlessly meet the conditions that are required to achieve your parents' love#and then not even being able to comprehend how to do that for yourself#it's about asking questions and being met with hostility for challenging the status quo#it's about experiencing unfairness and asking why and your parents' unflinching answer being:#because i'm your parent and i decide when things are fair#and i dont HAVE to figure out why i act this way much less make the adjustment to make it fair#anyway :))))))#fh#fantasy high#adaine abernant
59 notes
·
View notes
Text
Big props to Fromsoft for realising that if the most authoritarian character in Elden Ring was an epic badass who fights for their beliefs, there would be legions of the most annoying people possible crowing about how based they are, so instead they made Goldmask an ascetic pacifist with no combat abilities who died from doing too much math and upon resurrection as a candidate for the next shaper of reality, does nothing except stand naked and silent, then did so much math he died again.
#one may question if goldmask is truly an authoritarian if he seeks absolutely nothing in terms of personal gain#but I think if you rewrite the laws of reality to make everyone incapable of changing the status quo that makes you authoritarian#even if the new status quo turns out pretty good#things won't get worse but they also can't get any better#elden ring#goldmask
82 notes
·
View notes
Text
qsmp francophone cubitos and their dynamic drive me wild, they all know they’re mutually lying and obscuring the truth to one another, they all know they’re keeping each other at arm’s distance, they all know they’re not as open as they once were when it was just them and the aftermath of a plane crash, but the love is still there. the worry and the concern. they pry information out of one another in supposedly subtle ways that really just convey how much they still care about each other. what’s your stance on the federation. how’s your code arm doing. even if in the end you don’t turn to me, please call out to someone. maybe looking out for yourself is looking out for others as well. i don’t know you anymore but i will protect the unknown anyway
#qsmp#qsmp french#jay rambles#i need to go sleep . said i’d go to sleep ages ago . rotating them in my mind anw . fawk#it’s like. they KNOW they’re not being frank with one another. and it’s almost a game they play#i ask you this question and you know what i mean . but i will not say it outright .#for how long can we dance around the topic until one of us spills the obvious out into the open air#<- etoiles broke first btw lmao . and he and baghera went right back to pretending like neither of them knew any better too#insane of them . fuck#(for context it was about bbh and ron . both him and baghz were prodding at each other trying to gauge how much the other knew#and etoiles at one point just said ‘oh my god i know you know baghera !!! please !!!!’ it was a very validating moment for french cubito#enjoyers . right until they went back to pretending nothing had happened . win)#shoutout to like two months ago when etoiles said smth along the lines of how baghera isn’t telling him everything bc she doesn’t trust him#i will explode and explode and explode#antoine’s whole Thing early on about being distrustful and wary of others and how it hurt that he wasn’t always told everything anymore#a slow unraveling of the status quo that you don’t even realised has happened until you look around you
109 notes
·
View notes
Text
incredible that Final Fantasy X of all things continues to be like the only modern story with an allegory for racism/religious oppression that is actually accurate.
#the al bhed did nothing wrong there was no tangible reason for yevonites to target them#other than that they threatened yevon's religious authority by questioning the status quo and were a good scapegoat#theyre not inherently more dangerous nor was there any catalyst they were actually responsible for#just like in real life#because thats how racism works#and its in fucking final fantasy x#a great game with the simplest corniest story imaginable#i used the word allegory here but its barely even an allegory#ff10#final fantasy#shiv.txt
10 notes
·
View notes
Text
Riot Kings, page 154
prev next
#riotkings#whump comic#angst#emotional whump#gore#blood#implied death#nabi's audacity to ask questions and go against the status quo is growing to be a thorn in the Fleet's side lol
75 notes
·
View notes
Text
One of my coworkers got engaged (good for her!) but I looked around our meeting today (largely women) and realized that every single one of them was wearing basically the same diamond ring & got soooooo skeeved out… can’t even put my finger on why (heteronormativity? “Tiny collars” as an old friend used to call engagement rings?) but it left such a bad taste in my mouth 😬
#idk I think the way everyone was talking about it and the ring connection just made me realize how many people just…. don’t challenge or#even really question the status quo#obviously people are allowed to want & value whatever they choose but the uniformity of those choices is like. uncreative to me lol
13 notes
·
View notes
Note
Alr I'm back! Is the bachelor party still going?
Alastor!
Truth: Did you like the lapdance Vox gave you?
Dare: steal his hat and wear it for the rest of the game
—bird anon
"I mostly found it ridiculous."
#just wrapping up the last questions then it'll go back to status quo#bird anon#bchlr#AV#alastor#hazbin hotel alastor#hazbin hotel ask blog#ask blog#rp blog#hazbin hotel roleplay#hazbin hotel rp blog
8 notes
·
View notes